20 Songs About Indecision

As someone who has grappled with indecision more times than I can count, I know firsthand how crippling it can be. That moment of hesitation, when you’re paralyzed by the fear of making the wrong choice, can feel like an eternity. It’s a state of limbo that leaves us feeling lost, uncertain, and often regretful.

But here’s the thing: indecision is a universal experience. We all face it at some point in our lives, whether it’s choosing a career path, deciding on a relationship, or simply picking a restaurant for dinner. It’s a testament to the human condition that we struggle with making choices, even when the stakes are relatively low.

That’s why I’ve compiled a list of 20 songs that capture the essence of indecision. These tunes speak to the inner turmoil we feel when faced with a decision, the self-doubt that creeps in, and the relief (or regret) that comes with finally making a choice. They’re a reminder that we’re not alone in our struggles, and that even the most confident among us have moments of uncertainty.

1. “I Can’t Make Up My Mind” by The Zombies

“I Can’t Make Up My Mind” by The Zombies is a song that delves into the emotional turmoil of indecision within a romantic context. The protagonist is caught in a state of confusion, unable to decide whether to return to a past lover who is eager to rekindle their relationship. The lyrics emphasize the protagonist’s need for guidance, as they repeatedly express uncertainty and a desire for someone to help them make this crucial decision. The chorus, with its plea for the protagonist to “come back home,” underscores the emotional weight and urgency of the situation, highlighting the lover’s longing and the pressure on the protagonist to make a choice.

2. “Bad Religion” by Frank Ocean

“Bad Religion” by Frank Ocean, although not listed in your query, is often associated with themes of indecision and inner conflict. The song portrays a struggle with unrequited love and the complexities of identity, particularly in the context of religion and sexuality. The lyrics describe a conversation with a taxi driver, where the protagonist seeks solace and understanding. The song’s central metaphor of “bad religion” reflects the pain of loving someone who cannot reciprocate those feelings, likening it to a one-sided devotion. This unfulfilled love and the protagonist’s internal battle with their identity create a poignant narrative about the difficulty of reconciling personal desires with societal expectations.

3. “Feels Like We Only Go Backwards” by Tame Impala

“Feels Like We Only Go Backwards” by Tame Impala captures the feeling of being stuck in a cycle of indecision and stagnation. The song’s lyrics express a sense of moving backwards despite efforts to progress, reflecting the frustration of being unable to break free from a repetitive pattern. This theme is often interpreted as being about a relationship where communication and emotional connection seem to falter, leaving the protagonist feeling trapped. The song’s psychedelic soundscape complements the introspective lyrics, creating a vivid depiction of the struggle to move forward when everything feels like it’s regressing.

4. “I Fall Apart” by Elton John

“I Fall Apart” by Elton John explores the emotional impact of indecision and loneliness. The lyrics convey a sense of vulnerability and the difficulty of coping with change and uncertainty. The protagonist feels lost without a significant other, struggling to fill the emotional void left by their absence. The recurring theme of falling apart underscores the fragility of the protagonist’s emotional state, with indecision hanging heavily in their heart. The song captures the essence of feeling adrift and the challenge of navigating life’s uncertainties without clear direction.

5. “Owner of a Lonely Heart” by Yes

“Owner of a Lonely Heart” by Yes addresses the paradox of choosing between loneliness and the risk of heartbreak. The song suggests that while being the “owner of a lonely heart” can be isolating, it is preferable to the pain of a broken heart. The lyrics encourage taking risks and embracing individuality, despite the fear of failure or emotional pain. The song’s message is about self-reliance and the importance of making one’s own decisions, even when faced with uncertainty and potential loneliness.

6. “Everybody Wants to Rule the World” by Tears for Fears

“Everybody Wants to Rule the World” by Tears for Fears explores the universal desire for power and control, highlighting the indecision and moral dilemmas that come with such ambitions. The song reflects on the consequences of power struggles and the fleeting nature of control. Its lyrics allude to global conflicts, such as the Cold War, and the personal conflicts individuals face when pursuing power. The song’s enduring relevance is attributed to its commentary on human nature and the persistent desire for dominance.

7. “Don’t Make Me Choose” by Nick Jonas

“Don’t Make Me Choose” by Nick Jonas delves into the difficulty of making tough decisions, particularly in relationships. The song’s protagonist is caught between two equally important aspects of their life, symbolized by the metaphor of choosing between the “left hand and right hand.” The lyrics express the frustration and emotional turmoil of being forced to make a choice when both options are significant. The song underscores the pain of indecision and the desire for understanding and support from loved ones.

8. “Mr. Moustache” by Nirvana

“Mr. Moustache” by Nirvana critiques societal norms and the pressure to conform, using irony to address themes of indecision and identity. The song mocks stereotypical “macho” attitudes and highlights the internal conflict of adhering to societal expectations versus embracing one’s true self. The lyrics suggest a struggle with indecision about whether to conform or rebel against societal norms. The song’s critique of narrow-mindedness and prejudice reflects the difficulty of making authentic choices in a conformist society.

9. “I Miss You” by Blink-182

“I Miss You” by Blink-182 is a song that delves into the emotional turmoil of longing and loss following the end of a relationship. The lyrics express a deep sense of indecision and regret, as the protagonists grapple with the absence of a significant other. The song’s gothic and melancholic tone is enhanced by its acoustic arrangement, featuring instruments like the stand-up bass and cello, which create a haunting atmosphere. References to pop culture, such as Tim Burton’s The Nightmare Before Christmas, add layers of nostalgia and emotional complexity. The song captures the struggle of moving on while being haunted by memories of a past relationship, reflecting the indecision of whether to reach out or let go.

10. “This Path Tonight” by Graham Nash

“This Path Tonight” by Graham Nash is a reflective song that captures the uncertainty and indecision of navigating life’s changes. Written during a period of personal transition, including his separation from his wife, the song explores themes of self-discovery and the courage needed to face an uncertain future. Nash’s introspective lyrics convey a journey of emotional exploration, as he seeks to find his path amid life’s unpredictability. The song’s folk-rock style complements its introspective nature, creating an intimate and contemplative listening experience.

11. “Choices” by Buzzcocks

“Choices” by Buzzcocks is a song that embodies the punk ethos of questioning societal norms and the pressures of making decisions. The lyrics reflect the frustration and confusion that come with having to make choices in a world that often demands conformity. The song’s energetic and rebellious tone is characteristic of the Buzzcocks’ style, using driving guitar riffs and catchy melodies to convey a sense of urgency and defiance. “Choices” captures the essence of indecision as a form of resistance against societal expectations, highlighting the struggle to maintain individuality in a conformist world.

12. “Peace of Mind” by Boston

“Peace of Mind” by Boston addresses the theme of finding balance and contentment in life, amidst the pressures of career and competition. The song’s lyrics emphasize the importance of prioritizing personal well-being over the relentless pursuit of success. The protagonist expresses a desire to break free from the corporate rat race and find peace within themselves. The song’s uplifting melody and harmonious vocal arrangements reinforce its message of seeking a more meaningful and fulfilling life. “Peace of Mind” resonates with listeners who feel caught between societal expectations and their own aspirations, capturing the indecision of choosing between career advancement and personal happiness.

13. “Do I Have to Come Right Out and Say It” by Buffalo Springfield

“Do I Have to Come Right Out and Say It” by Buffalo Springfield captures the emotional struggle of expressing one’s feelings directly. The song’s protagonist grapples with the indecision of whether to openly declare their love and admiration for someone. The lyrics convey a sense of vulnerability and hesitation, as the protagonist questions the necessity of verbalizing emotions that feel so apparent. This internal conflict is underscored by the gentle folk-rock melody, which mirrors the introspective nature of the song. The theme of indecision is central, highlighting the fear of rejection and the difficulty of taking emotional risks.

14. “Alcohol” by The Kinks

“Alcohol” by The Kinks tells the story of a man whose life spirals into chaos due to his dependence on alcohol. The song portrays the man’s indecision and inability to control his drinking habits, which lead to personal and social downfall. The narrative illustrates how alcohol becomes a crutch for dealing with life’s pressures and disappointments, ultimately leading to a life of indecision and regret. The song’s theatrical style and vivid storytelling emphasize the destructive nature of addiction and the internal conflict between desire and self-control.

15. “Rope” by Foo Fighters

“Rope” by Foo Fighters explores the turmoil of holding on in the face of emotional and situational breakdowns. The song’s lyrics vividly depict the struggle with indecision and the desperate plea for help or clarity. The metaphor of a rope represents the need for support and the tension between holding on and letting go. The protagonist feels trapped by indecision, as they grapple with the consequences of their choices and the fear of failure. The energetic rock instrumentation and Dave Grohl’s impassioned vocals convey the urgency and intensity of this internal battle.

16. “She’s Out of My Life” by Michael Jackson

“She’s Out of My Life” by Michael Jackson is a poignant ballad about the pain of losing a loved one. The song captures the indecision and regret that accompany a breakup, as the protagonist reflects on missed opportunities and emotional vulnerability. Michael Jackson’s heartfelt delivery and the song’s slow tempo enhance the emotional weight of the lyrics, which express a deep sense of loss and introspection. The indecision lies in the protagonist’s struggle to accept the finality of the breakup and the realization of their emotional dependency.

17. “Should I Stay Or Should I Go?” by The Clash

“Should I Stay Or Should I Go?” by The Clash is a quintessential song about indecision, capturing the internal conflict of whether to remain in a relationship or leave. The lyrics are direct and repetitive, reflecting the protagonist’s vacillation between staying and going. The song’s energetic punk rock style underscores the urgency and frustration of the decision-making process. The inclusion of Spanish backing vocals adds a playful yet chaotic element, enhancing the song’s theme of confusion and uncertainty. Despite its straightforward lyrics, the song’s catchy hook and driving rhythm have made it a timeless anthem for those grappling with indecision.

18. “I Need to Know” by Tom Petty & The Heartbreakers

“I Need to Know” by Tom Petty & The Heartbreakers is a high-energy rock song that deals with the anxiety and urgency of needing clarity in a relationship. The protagonist demands to know the truth about whether their partner intends to leave, encapsulating the tension and impatience that come with waiting for a definitive answer. The song’s brisk tempo and punchy instrumentation mirror the emotional intensity and restlessness of the lyrics. Petty’s delivery conveys a mix of bravado and vulnerability, reflecting the internal struggle of wanting to appear strong while desperately seeking resolution.

19. “Train Under Water” by Bright Eyes

“Train Under Water” by Bright Eyes explores themes of uncertainty and introspection, often interpreted as a metaphor for navigating life’s complexities and the indecision that accompanies it. The song’s lyrics depict a journey filled with doubt and reflection, as the protagonist grapples with their feelings and the direction of their life. The folk-rock arrangement, characterized by its gentle acoustic guitar and contemplative tone, complements the introspective nature of the song. This track captures the essence of feeling lost and the difficulty of making decisions when faced with life’s unpredictability.

20. “Torn” by Natalie Imbruglia

“Torn” by Natalie Imbruglia is a poignant expression of heartbreak and disillusionment, centered around the indecision and vulnerability experienced after a relationship falls apart. The song’s lyrics describe the protagonist’s realization that the idealized image of their partner was an illusion, leaving them feeling exposed and unsure of how to move forward. The melancholic melody and emotive delivery amplify the themes of confusion and emotional turmoil. “Torn” resonates with listeners who have experienced the pain of shattered expectations and the indecision that comes with picking up the pieces.

Submit Your Song to This Playlist

Do you have a track or song you’d like to feature on this playlist? If so, please fill out the form below for our evaluation.

Serena Whitfield

Serena Whitfield is the founder of PlaylistCurator.org. She’s a musician who writes songs for bands. She studied music at the University of Oxford and graduated with distinction. With her expertise, she knows how to review songs and understand what makes good and bad music. Every playlist on our platform is approved by her before publishing to maintain top-notch quality. If you want her to check out your song and maybe get featured on our playlist, submit your song for Serena to evaluate.